نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Many urban decisions and interventions are justified in the name of the public interest, even though the definition, manifestations, and conditions for realizing this concept remain persistently contested. This article aims to critique and empirically and theoretically extend the conventional conception of the public interest in urban planning. Its central question is how a realistic, balanced, and equitable conception of the public interest can be formulated in processes of physical-spatial urban transformation under conditions of conflict among diverse and sometimes opposing groups. Drawing on critical social and philosophical perspectives, the study examines the contested 57-hectare development project surrounding the Shahcheragh Shrine (A.S.) in Shiraz as a case study, with particular attention to the mechanisms of subjugation and resistance operating within it. The study adopts a qualitative, exploratory-explanatory design, guided by an agonistic logic within the framework of pluralist democracy and a systemic-historical approach. Directed content analysis and historical discourse analysis were employed. An initial narrative was constructed from media reports and subsequently verified through comparison with documentary evidence, field observations, conversations with local residents, and semi-structured interviews. Data collection continued until saturation was reached. The findings demonstrate that the public interest is neither a static, self-evident, nor pre-existing concept. Rather, it is constructed alongside three other forms of interest: interest for survival, interest for exchange, and interest for domination. Institutional authority, symbolic legitimacy, technical discourse, and resource allocation reinforced mechanisms of subjugation, while legal action, professional advocacy, civic mobilization, and counter-narratives sustained resistance. Within these configurations of power and the struggle between subjugation and resistance, different forms of interest are continually stabilized, redefined, prioritized, and transformed into one another. Therefore, the public interest can be realized not by eliminating conflict or imposing consensus, but by recognizing plurality, exposing power relations, establishing fair procedures, and enabling the effective participation of marginalized groups in decision-making processes.
کلیدواژهها English