Analysis of Suspension of conscription and Retention in Univerisity (Case Study: Students of University of Tehran)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Master in Sociology, Dpartment of Social Sciences, University of Tehran

2 Associate Professor, Dpartment of Social Sciences, University of Tehran

Abstract

Introduction: Conscription is a concern that is of great importance to young people and even their families at the current situation, therefore, several studies have addressed various aspects of this subjcet. The most important question of this dissertation is whether the boys with academic exemptions at the University of Tehran in postgraduate studies have retained in the university due to conscription suspension or not? In response to this question, the understanding of the mental arrays of boys with academic exemptions in postgraduate studies at the University of Tehran regarding the issue of retention in the higher education system has been examined with emphasis on the suspension of the conscription.
Method: Accordingly, the research was conducted using Q methodology and taking 48 statements from the c and collecting data from 119 participants, all of them were graduate students of the University of Tehran. This method is used to identify the subjectivity of the agents. Because the nature of the present study is exploratory, Q methodology will be the best option for data collection. For this purpose, after extracting the propositions, Q sorts were designed and data were collected from participants in the form of Q table. Factor analysis technique was used to analyze the data.
Findings: Analysis of participants' opinions using factor analysis technique identified the final 8 factors. Each of these eight mindsets addresses a particular understanding of the phenomenon of persistence in the higher education system in relation to the suspension of conscription, which has been examined in depth. The scales weigh a little heavier on the "suspenders". This group of agents each tries in some way to suspend the service by remaining in the higher education system. The other group of agents showed interest in the university but still agree with the first group on their aversion to military service. Among the extracted factors, the factor of "academians ready to serve" is a very different factor that indicates the relative tendency to both environments, and the factor of "interest seekers" also shows a utilitarian approach to both environments.
Results and Conclusions: Although the views of the participants could not be generalized to the whole community in Q methodology, the results clearly showed that conscription policies in Iran have not been effective for students and some are trying to suspend it through possible channels. Military policies in Iran put pressure on students and their families, as well as on the military and conscription system itself, and can alienate students from the university environment and reduce the efficiency of the military. It seems that the all-volunteer army that is being formed in many countries of the world can be a good option to change the military in Iran, but we must also pay attention to the different geographical, political, social and cultural characteristics of Iran in this change.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  • Alihosseini, A., Mahdian, H., & Rabieinia, B. (2015), Investigating the effect of military training course in Army Center 01 on social solidarity indicators, Strategic Research on Social Problems in Iran. No. 2: 101-112. (in Persian)
  • Barzin, M., Mirmiran, P., Ramezankhani, A., & Hatami H, Azizi F. (2009), Prevalence of Obesity in Young Tehranian Males (18-25y) Entering Military Service (Shahrivar 1386), Iranian Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism, No. 6 :605-613 (in Persian)
  • Bashatah, L. (2016), Q-methodology: What and how? IOSR Journal of Research Method in Education, No. 5: 37-43.
  • Brown, S.R. (1980), Political Subjectivity, Applications of Methodology in Political Science, Yale University Press, London.
  • Clever, M., & Segal, D. R. (2012), After conscription: The United States and the all-volunteer force, Sicherheit and Frieden, No. 1: 9–18.
  • Conley, D., & Heerwig, J. (2009), The long-term effects of military conscription on Mortality: Estimates from the VIETNAM-ERA draft lottery, Demography, No. 3.
  • Danaei Fard, H., Hosseini, S.Y., & Sheikhha, R. (2014), Q methodology: Theoretical foundations and research framework, Saffar: Tehran. (in Persian)
  • Dorri Nogoorani, H. (2002), Theory of economic analysis of the conscription, Scientific Journal of Defense Policy, No. 34: 7-46. (in Persian)
  • Firozjaeian, A., Janalizadeh, H., & Hashemiyan, B. (2017), Hysteresis in academic field and academic alienation (Case study: Students of Mazandaran University), Quarterly of Social Studies and Research in Iran, No. 1: 1-20. (in Persian)
  • Gonzalez-Cueva, E. (2000), Conscription and Violence in Peru, Latin American Perspectives, No. 3: 88–102.
  • Imbens, G., & van der Klaauw, W. (1995). Evaluating the Cost of Conscription in the Netherlands. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, No. 2: 207–215.
  • Institute for Research and Planning in Higher Education. (1995), Comparison of the total number of applicants by province of study and gender from the academic year 1374-1373 to the academic year 1383-1382, Published report, Retrieval from: www.irphe.ac.ir/files/site1/pages/Stat_1382_83/AddmittedStudentTabl/9.1.jpg. (in Persian)
  • Institute for Research and Planning in Higher Education. (2020), Higher education statistics in Iran at a glance, Published report, Retrieval from: https://irphe.ac.ir/files/Statistic/files/Amar1Negah/1398-99.pdf. (in Persian)
  • Jallinoja, P., Tuorila, H., Ijajarvi, A., Bingham, C., Uutela, A., & Absetz, P. (2011), Conscripts' attitudes towards health and eating: Changes during the military service and associations with eating, Appestite, NO. 57: 718–721.
  • Keller, K., Wagener, A., & Poutvaara, P. (2010), Does a Military Draft Discourage Enrollment in Higher Education? FinanzArchiv, No. 2: 97-120.
  • Khoshgoyanfard, A. (2008), Q methodology. IRIB Research Center: Tehran. (in Persian)
  • Mahdizadeh, M., & Hashemi, S.Z. (2018), Sociological Analysis of Factors Affecting Social Demand for Ph.D. (Case Study of Ph.D Students of Tehran Universities), Quarterly of Social Studies and Research in Iran, No. 4: 819-846. (in Persian)
  • Mansoorfar, K. (2017), Advanced statistical methods with computer programs, University of Tehran Publications: Tehran. (in Persian)
  • Mohammadi, H. (2017), Investigating the effect of military service on psychological empowerment, personality traits and mental health of soldiers, Master thesis, Humanities faculty, Islamic Azad Univeristy of Shahrood. (in Persian)
  • Nicholas, J. B. (2011), Reliability in Q Methodology: A Case Study. The Eastern Education Research Association Annual Conference, Akron, Ohio.
  • Pham, P. N., Vinick, P., & Stover, E. (2009), Returning home: forces conscription, reintegration, and mental health status of former abductees of the Lord's Resistance Army in northern Uganda, BMC Psychiatry, No. 23.
  • Poutvaara, P., & Wagener, A. (2007), Conscription: Economic costs and political allure, The Economics of Peace and Security Journal, 1.
  • Seyedi, S.M.; Seyedi, S.H., & Salavatian, S. (2016), Understanding the experience essence of serving soldiers with higher education, phenomenological research, Strategic Research on Social Problems in Iran, No. 3: 67-86. (in Persian)
  • Sinaee, V. (2010), Modern state, national military and conscription, Research in Theoretical Policies, No. 7: 95-111. (in Persian)
  • Sinaee, V. (2016), Examination of Students' Attitude towards Conscription: the case study of Mashhad Ferdowsi University students, Research Letter of Political Science, No. 1: 95-118.
  • Soltani, M., & Mohammadian, B. (2016), Discourse analysis of Hesitant Customers mental models, Journal of Business Management, No. 2: 339-354. (in Persian)
  • Statistical Centre of Iran. (2017), Male students in different courses of higher education institutions according to the field of study, Published report, Retrieval from: https://www.amar.org.ir/Portals/0/PropertyAgent/461/Files/9708/1203z130559697.xlsx. (in Persian)
  • Toosi, A. (2001), The effect of the quarterly military training course on the general physical training of the soldiers of Shahid Sabetkhah Barracks in Kermanshah, Master Thesis, Faculty of Physical Education, Tarbiat Moallem University. (in Persian)