Critical Approach to Commodification of health and exclusion of the poor elderly

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Professor of the Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

2 Assistant Professor of the Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

3 PhD in Sociology, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction: In the society of Iran, health is a valuable commodity which is sold in the market. In this situation, we can speak about “commodification of health”. The result of commodification will be treating it as something for obtaining benefits. In such a condition, Monetization, market values and inequality will increase. It seems that the Iranian society gradually have had some paradigm changes in heath discourse and the government’s economic withdrawal in general supplying of health services and expansion of the private sector in the health system. In this discourse the patient is considered as a costumer who must provide the expenses of his health and treatment. Furthermore, health is considered as a personal commodity rather than a public one which all people have the right of access to it. In such a system, instead of patient’s need, patient’s purchasing power is the criterion for access to health services. Therefore, the current study is that what are the consequences of health commodification for the elderly as the regular consumers of health system?
Method: This study has been done through “Qualitative Research” and “in-depth and Semi-Structured Interviews” with 28 elderly people in Tehran (people over 65 years old). To identify the elderly has been used a combination of purposeful samplings such as “Maximum Variation Sampling” and “Theoretical sampling”. The Maximum Variation sampling is used for finding the elderly in various types and theoretical sampling is used to achieve conceptual saturation. Finally, the interview data were coded and categorized by “Thematic analysis”. Besidesthe qualitative research, the health related documents have been investigated.  
Results and discussion: The results indicated that classified health, poor governmental health system and ignored the poor elderly are amongst the consequences of Commodification of health for the elderly in low social classes and at last will be resulted in exclusion and ignorance of the poor elderly. Other consequences of Commodification of health can be pointed to the feeling of class exclusion, increasing poverty among the poor people, removing health from consumption basket, financial inability of the poor and turn to self-curing. The greatest victims of the health system are the poor and ill elderly who because of their age are the fixed customers of the health and treatment system. As the poor elderly live in an insecure and inflammatory economic society, will be resulted in providing some essentials for their life and sometimes they will remove health services from their consumption basket. Commodification of health will be resulted in classified health and it will be continued to the classified differences in having access to health services. As a result of all this differences and inequalities the experience of ageing in the Iranian society will turn into a multiple experience and the rich elderly have a good access to the commodified health system. As a result, the economic capital is considered as an important factor in the ageing experience.      
Conclusion: In commodification of health condition, the poor elderly share is nothing but exclusion. Nowadays the Iranian government needs to be more responsible for the poor elderly. The Iranian government must de-commodification of health services and consider it as an essential commodity. Furthermore, paying attention to Prevention and general care besides cure in social health policy for the elderly is important.

Keywords

References

  • Abazari, Y., & Zakeri, A. (2019), Three Decades of Association between Religion and Neoliberalism in Iran, Critique of Political Economy, Retrieved from https://pecritique.com/2019/02/24/ (In Persian)
  • Alston, P. (2018), Extreme poverty and human rights, United Nations, General Assembly, Retrieved from

https://undocs.org/A/HRC/38/33/ADD.1.

  • Bagheri, Y., & Abdi, R. (2019), Reflections on the Demands of Retirees, Tehran: Saba Pension Strategies Institute. (In Persian)
  • Baltussen, R., Mikkelsen, E., Tromp, N., Hurtig, A., Byskov, J., Olsen, O., Bæroe, K., Hontelez, J.A., Singh, J., & Norheim, O.F. (2013), “Balancing Efficiency: Equity and Feasibility of HIV Treatment in South Africa Development of Programmatic Guidance”, Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation, No. 26: 1-9.
  • Bastani, S., Rahnama, F., & Ghazinejad, M. (2013), “Social Exclusion Case: Subjective and Objective Exclusion Tehranian's Elderly”, Quarterly of Social Studies and Research in Iran, No. 2, 599-626. (In Persian)
  • Bonoli, G., George, V., & Taylor-Gooby, P. (2001), European Welfare Futures: Towards a Theory of Retrenchment, Translated by Hormoz Homayounpour, Tehran: Social Security Organization Research Institute. (In Persian)
  • Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006), “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology”, Qualitative Research in Psychology, No. 2: 77-101.
  • Callinicos, A. (2004), Social Theory a Historical Introduction, Translated by Akbar Masoom Beigi, Tehran: Agah Publications. (In Persian)
  • Center for Statistics and Strategic Information (2019), Study of Health Costs and Social and Medical Insurance in the Consumption Basket of Households in the Country – 2018, Tehran: Ministry of Cooperatives, Labor and Social Welfare (In Persian)
  • Center for Statistics and Strategic Information (2020), Study of Health Costs and Social and Medical Insurance in the Consumption Basket of Households in the Country: 2011-2019, Tehran: Ministry of Cooperatives, Labor and Social Welfare (In Persian)
  • Gholami, S. (2017), The Study of the Share of Health Care Costs of Families with Elderly Members, Tehran: Saba Pension Strategies Institute. (In Persian)
  • Harvey, D. (2012), A Brief History of Neoliberalism, Translated by Mahmoud Abdullahzadeh, Tehran: Dot Publication. (In Persian)
  • Jafari Sirizi, M., Rashidian, A., Abolhasani, F., Mohammad, K., Yazdani, Sh., Parkerton, P., Younesian, M., Akbari, F., & Arab, M. (2008), “Qualitative Assessment of Dimensions and Degree of Autonomy Granting to University Hospitals”, Hakim Research Journal, No. 11 (2): 59-71. (In Persian)
  • Jakab, M., Preker, A. S., & Harding, A. (2003), The Missing Link? Hospital Reform in Transition Economies, In A. L. Harding and A. S. Preker (Ed.), Innovations in Health Service Delivery: The Corporatization of Public Hospitals, Health, Nutrition, and Population, (PP. 207-238), Washington DC: World Bank,
  • Jalaeipour, H., & Bayangani, B. (2016), “Sociological Study of the Economic Consequences of the Market and Border Trade (Critical Ethnography of Baneh Border Market)”, Quarterly of Social Studies and Research in Iran, No. 5: 539-573. (In Persian)
  • Leon, D. A., Walt, G., & Gilson, L. (2001), “Recent Advances: International Perspectives on Health Inequalities and Policy”, British Medical Journal, No. 322: 591-594.
  • Marx, K. (1973), Capital, Translated by Iraj Eskandari, Volume 1. Tehran: Tudeh Party of Iran Publication. (In Persian)
  • McGregor, S. (2001), “Neoliberalism and Health Care”, International Journal of Consumer Studies, No. 25: 82–89.
  • Mirzaie, M., & Darabi, S. (2017), “Population Aging in Iran and Rising Health Care Costs”, Salmand: Iranian Journal of Ageing, No. 12: 156-169. (In Persian)
  • Norman, A. H., Russell, A. J., & Merli, C. (2016), “The Quality and Outcomes Framework: Body Commodification in UK General Practice”, Social Science and Medicine, No. 170: 77-86.
  • Parvaei, S. (2019), Ageing in Transition Of Iranian Society Changes, PhD dissertation in Sociology, Supervisors: Taghi Azad Armaki & Majid Koosheshi, Tehran, University of Tehran, Faculty of Social Sciences. (In Persian)
  • Parvaei, S. (2020), Typology of Consumption Behavior of Retirees, Tehran: Saba Pension Strategies Institute. (In Persian)
  • Parvaii, S & mousaei, M. (2020), Exclusion of Ageing in Social Policy Analyzing Development Plans after the Revolution, Journal of Social Problems of Iran; No. 2: 59-83. (In Persian)
  • Peikanpour, M., Esmaeli, S., Yousefi, N., Aryaeinezhad, A., & Rasekh, H. (2018), “A Review of Achievements and Challenges of Iran’s Health Transformation Plan”, Payesh, No. 17: 481-494. (In Persian)
  • Petrovici, D., & Christopher, R. (2006), “Population Health and Risk Factors in Transitional Economy”, Journal of Consume Policy, No. 29: 279-300.
  • Sakellariou, D., & Rotarou, E. S. (2017), “The Effects of Neoliberal Policies on Access to Healthcare for People with Disabilities”, International Journal for Equity in Health, No. 16: 1-8.
  • Saksena, P., Xu, K., & Durairaj, V. (2010), The Drivers of Catastrophic Expenditure: Outpatient Services, Hospitalization or Medicines, Background Paper, No. 21, World Health Organization.
  • Sampath, P., & Wilson, D. M. (2012), “A Case Study and State of Science Review: Private Versus Public Healthcare Financing”, Global Journal of Health Science, No. 4: 118–126.
  • Sandel, M. J. (2014), What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets, Translated by Hassan Afshar, Tehran: Markaz Publication. (In Persian)
  • Sharifzadegan, M. H. (2018), Inequality in Social Welfare and Its Pathological Consequences,In the Second Report on the Social Status of Iran 2009-2017: Social Solidarity and Inequality (Volume 1), by Mirtaher Mousavi,Tehran: Agah Publications. (In Persian)
  • Somkotra, T. L., & Lagrada, P. (2009), “Which Households Are at Risk of Catastrophic Health Spending: Experience in Thailand after Universal Coverage”, Health Affairs, No. 28: 467-478.
  • Statistical Center of Iran (1956-2016), Detailed Results of the General Census of Population and Housing of the whole country, Tehran: Statistical Center of Iran (In Persian)
  • Tajmazinani, A. (2011), “A Typology of Welfare Systems around the World”, Journal of Welfare Planning and Social Development, No. 2: 203-234. (In Persian)
  • Taylor, G. (2013), Ideology and Welfare, Translated by Hossein Mohagheghi Kamal and Mehdi Nosratabadi, Tehran: Sociologists Publications. (In Persian)
  • Vandenberghe, F. (2007), The Sociology of George Simmel, Translated by Abdolhossein Nikgohar, Tehran: Totia Publication. (In Persian)
  • Yip, W., & Hsiao, W. (2014), “Harnessing the Privatization of China’s Fragmented Health-Care Delivery”, Lancet, No. 384: 805-18.

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics