State Crime; A new Approach to the Analysis of Social Harms (Case Study: Street Children in Tehran)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Professor of Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh TabatabaʼiUniversity, Tehran, Iran

2 PhD, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh TabatabaʼiUniversity, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction: Despite the consequences of social harms, however, these harms are usually considered as social issues, not legal-criminal ones, traditionally. The common perception of these harms has led to focus on the reason more than considering governor’s responsibility to create and maintain them. The phenomenon of street children as one of the most important social harms in Iranian society, although it has been considered in various aspects, taking into account the responsibility for the government, is ignored. In recent decades, and under the guise of a so-called Statecrime approach, Statesas criminals, have also been held criminally liable for these damages nowadays. Examining the causes of the creation and continuation of this phenomenon, along with examining the duties and responsibilities of different authorities and institutions in this regard, can be very effective in explaining this issue from the perspective of the State's criminal responsibility.
Method: According to the interviews with street children, the research method of this research is qualitative and its sampling has been done purposefully. Despite the fact that after interviewing 61 street children, saturation was achieved due to the similarity between their statements, however, in order to increase the accuracy of the research results, the interview was conducted with the entire research community (100 people).Giving the interviews, then they were analyzed using an open coding method and the results were presented under the etiology of street children.
Finding: The findings of the present study, which were obtained by examining the common theories of government crime and study of 100 street children in Tehran, show that poverty (in the concept of not meeting the basic needs of life), family problems (such as separation or Parental differences, physical or verbal violence at home, parental addiction or one of them and so on.), high living costs (especially in the metropolis of Tehran) and children's need for entertainment and freedom are the most important reasons for the street children phenomenon and its continuation. Although none of the interviewees mentioned in their answers the factors of working for other people and being exploited, however, economic exploitation of these children is an issue that can certainly be considered as a factor for the phenomenon of street children.
Results & Conclusion: The results of this study indicate that along with the existing reasons for creating the phenomenon of street children, neglect of various institutions and authorities at different levels of decision and implementation, is one of the most important reasons for the development of this phenomenon in Iranian society. Although Iran's penal code is mostly insufficient to respond to perpetrators of government crime, it is still possible to provide minimum responses to these individuals regarding their responsibility to street children.

Keywords


  • Benitez, S.T. de (2007) State of the World’s Street Children: Violence, London: Consortium for Street Children Press.
  • Golami, N and Abbasi, M (2016), "Introduction of Governmental Crime in light of Principles of Bioethics, Bioethics Journal, No. 24: 83-97.
  • Gholami, N (2019), Prevention of State Crime in Light of Elements of Good Governencem, PhD Thesis in Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Lwa and Political Science of Allameh Tabatabae University.
  • Green, P, and Ward, T (2017), State Crime: Governments, Violence and Corruption, Translated by Nabiollah Gholami, Tehran: Majd Press.
  • Hillyard, P,and  Tombs, S. (2008), Beyond criminology ?, in Criminal obsessions: Why harm matters more than crime. London, Pluto: 6-23.
  • Kozarich D, Mateo R, nad Miler WJ.(2011), Victiminology of State Crimes, Journal of Deputy of Research, Education & Citizenship Rights, No. 21: 102-137.
  • Najafai Abrandabadi, AH (2010), "From Criminology to Zemiology", Research Law Journal, No.56: 1015- 1032.
  • Najafai Abrandabadi, AH, and Hasenbeigi, H (2010), Lexicon of Criminology, Tehran: Ganje Danesh Press.
  • Roch, JL (1975), Sociology of Poverty, Translated by Ahmad Karimi, Tehran: Amirkabir Press.
  • Roncevic N, Stojadinovic A, Batrnek-AntonicD, (2013) "Street children", Journal of Srpski arhiv za celokupnolekarstvo. No. 12: 835-841.
  • Rosenblatt, FF (2018), "The Victimization of Street Childreen in Brazil", in Victimology of State Crime, Edited by Roth, Dl and Kazelarich D, Tehran: The SD Institute of Law Research and Study.
  •  Ross, J.I (2010), The Development of Political Crime, translaterd by Hossein Gholami, Tehran, The Organization for Researching and Composing University textbooks in the Humanities Press.
  • Roth, Dawn L, David Kauzlarich (2014), Towards Victimology of State Crime, London: Routledge.
  • Sahriari, B and Shamsnateri, ME (2015), " extensive social hazards in the transition of schools and ideas of criminal law and criminology", Enviromental Hazards Journal, No. 13: 275- 289.
  • Van Ham, F (2012), Zemiology: New discipline, development of criminology, in  Encyclopedia of Criminal Sciences, Tehran, Mizan Press: 917- 929.
  •  Viliams, FP, and Macshin, MD (2011), Criminological Theory, Trnslated by Hamid Reza Malek Mohamadi, Tehran: Mizan Press.
  • Vogel, A., and M.S. Mello, (1991),“Da cada a rua: a cidade como fascinio e descaminho.” In O Trabalho e a Rua: Crianças e Adolescentes no Brasil Urbano dos Anos 80, A. Fausto and R. Cervini (eds), 133-50. Sao Paulo: 50-133
  • White, R, and Hinz, F (2012), Crime and Criminology, Translated by Ali Salimi, Qom, Research Institute of Hawzeh and University Press.