The Sociological Analysis of Narratives of Iranian Women Married to Afghan-Iraqi Men

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Sociology (Social Science) Alzahra University

2 Master of Sociology, Alzahra University

Abstract

Introduction: For many years, Iran has witnessed the influx of male immigrants from its eastern and western neighbors who entered the country in large numbers. For many different reasons, they decide to marry Iranian girls. Albeit, Iranian women married to foreign nationals do not possess a clear legal and lawful status. On the other hand, even though for these married Iranian women there is a refugee policy in terms of either returning to their homelands with their lawful husbands or to stay in Iran in a wedlock or; husbands leaving them behind and return to their homeland all together, nevertheless, this kind of marriage leave them with so much mental, psychological, economic, cultural and social sufferings. Social exclusion is a multidimensional discipline which covers ranges of economic, social and political concepts. It is defined as the lack of participation in social activities and institutions and the violation of human and civil rights of people involved.
Method: The present paper, under the umbrella concept of social exclusion, has dealt with this issue by employing the method of in-depth interview of 35 Iranian women married to Iraqi nationals and 21 Iranian women married to Afghan nationals, ages from 23 to 66 years old conducted in the city of Neyshabur, Iran.
Findings: Based on these interviews, we found that the lack of knowledge about the consequences of marrying to a foreign national, poverty and deprivation, are the main reasons for an Iranian woman marrying to a foreign national. Subsequently, by marrying a foreign national, these women would suffer from the feelings of social humiliation, misery and inequality thereof. They get deprived from their civil rights, such that birth certificate is not issued for their children thus, they would not be considered as Iranian nationals. Furthermore, although living in a grave poverty, they are not eligible for receiving any government subsidies and/or allowances.
Conclusion: Exclusion and deprivation of a woman married to a foreign national from the time prior to the marriage, living with her parents and after marriage, living in her shared marital life, exclude and deprive her from her social lives. Although exclusion of these women in their childhood period is relatively high in both groups, nevertheless in the case of Iranian women married to the foreign nationals, this amount is much higher. The feeling of humiliation is also higher in the Iranian women married to Afghan nationals than in women married to the Iraqi nationals. The accumulated exclusion and deprivation among the women under study are correlated to the family structure, chronic and inter-generation poverty and their present condition.

Keywords


  • Abbasi-shavazi,M ohammad jalal, Glazebrook, Diana, Jamshidih, Gholamreza,Mahmodian, Hossien, Sadeghi, Rasoul, (2008), Second-generation Afghans in Iran: Integration, Identity and Return, Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit (AREU).  
  • Bailey, Nick, Fahmy, Eldin, Bradshaw (2017), The Multi- dimensional Analysis of Social Exclusion, in Bramley, G. and Bailey, N. (eds), “Poverty and social exclusion in the UK: volume 2 - the dimensions of disadvantage”, Bristol: Policy Press:311-42.
  • chalabi, Massoud (2010), “Theoretical Analysis of the Origin and Relationship of Social Norms andInequality”, Journal of Social Analysis, (Social Order and Inequality), Institute of Humanities, No 14: 1-26.
  • Eimani naeeni, Mohsen,Sadeghi, Mahmood, Abdi, Ftemeh, (2o12), Possibility of Extension the Legal Protections of Marriage with Foreign Nationals, Women’s  Strategic Studies, No14: 91-134.
  • Firrouzabadi, Ahmad, Sadeghi, Alireza, (2010), An Investigation on the Dimensions of Social Exclusion of the Rural Female Households in Terms of Employment and Residence, Woman in Development and Politics, V8, 93-114.
  • Ghaffari, GHolamreza, Tajedin, Mohammad Bagher,(2005), The Enquiry of Social DeprivationDimensions.  Social welfare, No17:33-56.
  • Goffman, Irving, (2007), Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity, Halal Weekly, Sunday 11/2/84, p.5.
  • Hobcraft .J. (2007), Child ,development , the life course , and social exclusion: Are the frameworks used in the UK relevant for developing countries Department of Social Policy and Social Work, University of York, Heslington.
  • Katozian, Nasser (2003) "Family Civil Rights", Tehran, Bahman, Borna.
  • Kenyon, Susan et al. (2002), "Transport and Social Exclusion: Investigating the Possibility of Promoting   Inclusion through Virtual mobility",Journal of Transport Geography,V10:10-28.
  • Kenyon, Susan, et al (2002), “Transport and Social Exclusion: Investigating the Possibility of Promoting Inclusion through Virtual mobility”, Journal of Transport Geography, No 10:10-28.
  • Kgalajabadi Farahani, Farideh, Saraei, Hasan, (2016), Exploration of underlying factors for single child intention and behavior in Tehran; a Qualitative Study, Women’s Strategic Studies, V18: 29-58.
  • Peace, Robin, (2001), “Social Exclusion: A Concept IN Need of Definition?”, Social Policy Journal of New Zealand ,V16: 17-35.
  • Public Relations and Information Unit of the General Department of Citizens and Foreign Immigrants of Khorasan Razavi, (2013) "Refugee History in the Islamic Republic of Iran".
  • Rohani,Sara, Rohani, Sima, ( 2014), “Afghan Immigrants in Iran and Citizenship”, Journal of Public Administration and Governance, V4:18-28.
  • Salehi Esfahan, javad. (2007), Youth exclusion in Iran: the state of education, employment and family formation, Middle east Youth initiative working paper.
  • Silver, Hilary, (2007), the process of social exclusion: the dynamics of an evolving concept, USA, Chronic Poverty Research Centre, SSRN.
  • translated by Manouchehr, Sabouri Kashani, Tehran, Shirazeh.
  • Zahidi, Ashraf, (2007), “Transnational Marriages, Gendered Citizenship, and the Dilemma of Iranian Women Married to Afghan Men”, Iranian Studies, No 40: 225-139.
  • Zahidi, Ashraf, (2007), “Transnational Marriages, Gendered Citizenship, and the Dilemma of Iranian Women Married to Afghan Men”, Iranian Studies, V40, 225-139.
  • Zarghani, Hadi,  Gholami, Yones,Ghanbar, Mohammad, Ghiasi, mohammad hosein, Hoseini, mostafa, (2016), Analysis of Spatial Distribution of Afghan Immigrants in Khorasan Razavi Province during 2003-2001 (Planning Plan 5 to 9), Urban planning, V27,127-146.